Bringing ideas to life

Wrapt In a Brown Mantle

Published in Dirty Looks by Mark Murphy on December 18, 2012


(c) Barabeke

The line ‘wrapt in a brown mantle’ is taken from T.S. Eliot‘s poem The Waste Land. It is part of a section (lines 359-365) that was inspired by an experience Sir Ernest Shackleton had on one of his expeditions. Detailed in his book South, Shackleton describes how he was convinced that he and his colleagues were joined by an invisible presence on the final traumatic part of their journey. According to him, ‘it seemed to me often that we were four, not three’.

These are the lines from The Waste Land in full:

Who is the third who walks always beside you?
When I count, there are only you and I together
But when I look ahead up the white road
There is always another one walking beside you
Gliding wrapt in a brown mantle, hooded
I do not know whether a man or a woman
—But who is that on the other side of you?

Eliot may have been aware that there were other recorded instances of the ‘Third Man Factor’ – a kind of guardian angel presence, an unseen guiding hand for those in peril. Certainly the experience seems much more common than given credit for – something extensively covered in John Geiger‘s book The Third Man Factor, which provides numerous accounts of the presence from the likes of sailors, climbers, polar explorers, even 9/11 survivors. Other references to the Third Man Factor can be found elsewhere, in particular the biblical parallels where Christ, resurrected, appeared to two of his disciples on the Road to Emmaus, and walks along beside them.

It’s therefore not surprising that spiritual claims have been made on behalf of the Third Man, alongside

English: Thomas Stearns (‘T.S.’) Eliot with his sister and his cousin, by Lady Ottoline Morrell (died 1938). See source website for additional information. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

more scientific/psychological attempts at understanding the phenomenon (third man as coping mechanism, for example). But such a phenomenon cannot be left to the vagaries of the faith or reason brigade, especially not when there are other stories that can and should be told about the Third Man. One only has to make reference to the likes of Jessica Benjamin, and her psychoanalytic concept of the ‘shared third’ to suggest that something else might be going on with the Third Man. I’ve argued before that the shared third finds its natural home in the relational world, but in order to make a decisive leap between the two concepts, the shared third must be considered as some form of presence, as a ‘thing’ that exists in its own right.

Of course this is conjecture, but it is striking how the Third Man as experienced by so many, is experienced as presence. But not only that; as an unseen and also watchful presence. And is this not what the relational world is? An unseen watchful presence? The experience of trauma and peril may be such that the relational world manifests itself more clearly, more physically, such experiences coaxing the relational world out of its shadow existence. At the very least, this explanation is as plausible as any others so far put forward. Regardless, however we may want to configure the relational world – as God, as spirit, as ethic, as the Third Man even, they always seem to be different attempts at answering the same question, Eliot’s question: who is that on the other side of you?

Source: Dirty Looks – Why Hell is Other People

Spread the love!

About the author /


Avatar

Mark Murphy is a Reader in Education and Public Policy at the University of Glasgow. He previously worked as an academic at King’s College, London, University of Chester, University of Stirling, National University of Ireland, Maynooth, University College Dublin and Northern Illinois University. Mark is an active researcher in the fields of education and public policy. His research interests include educational sociology, critical theory, accountability in higher education, and public sector reform.

Post your comments

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *